Design Flaw?? (1 Viewer)

[Vic. Parsons.]

QUOTE="fiferjim, post: 4146556, member: 62747"]
Update
A number of funsters suggested the hinges may be adjusted. Had another look but they still don't look adjustable to me which suggests the door is in the correct position, or am I missing something? Thanks again guys
[/QUOTE]

It looks to me like there may be a small amount of adjustment on the door part of the hinge. Where the hinge is cranked, there is a slight gap between it and the door's outer frame. Closing this gap will move the door further in, therefore tightening it on the seal. The hinge screws will be secured into a sliding metal plate set in the aluminium channel of the door ( you can just make out the plate in your second picture), depending on how tight a fit the plate is, there should be some movement available.
Since the top looks ok, I would slacken the lower hinge or hinges and see if you can close that gap.

 

[JJ]

Sorry in advance for taking advantage of your bad luck but this seems another example of the much vaunted build quality of 'premium' German m/hs

Meow, meow...

JJ

 

[Pekepal]

Sorry in advance for taking advantage of your bad luck but this seems another example of the much vaunted build quality of 'premium' German m/hs

After 5 years and many touring miles in our Burstner we feel blessed that we have only experienced minor problems compared to many others. Would definitely buy another if we ever decided to part with DorisTG which is extremely unlikely.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[gwyntaxi]

Worth a punt! I appreciate the heads up. Do you happen to know what the deflector is exactly or where to get it? Ta

It’s a Fiamma accessory, Johns cross, Caravans will mail you a roll, as I remember it was £33 for a 3metre length including postage, it has self adhesive strip on it to fix, it sticks well too, just warm I up in the sun or warm water to make it more pliable

 

[Ian Bosman]

I'll check it out, and thanks for the link. Self adhesive sounds good to me!

My Fiamma drip stop is self adhesive and has stayed put for two years, touch wood!

 

[bigalw35]

2001 MB Sprinter Hymer B680,
door catches incorrectly placed, by Hymer. The door catch protrudes within the opening space, several times I've caught and gouged my arm and ended up with scars.
The first two pics are the "drivers door - RHD"
The next two are the "passenger door"

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[KUSKUS]

We also own a Hymer b 680 but ours have spring covers to stop you catching yourselves on it.

 

[bigalw35]

Cheers KUSKUS, no real need to ask, but I suppose that they were fitted when you brought it ?

 

[fiferjim]

bigalw35 - that's not good, no wonder you catch your arm on it!

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[KUSKUS]

Yes 2006 model 680 , must have done a modification to original specification.
It only screws over the top of the existing fitting perhaps you could get it from Brownhills at Newark ask Darren he would know.

 

[bigalw35]

Daren and I are quite good mates (over the years) I’ll email him later, but I think it’s a slim chance, cheers KUSKUS
Cheers
AL

 

[Ian Bosman]

these pictures show the door catch on my EuraMobil, 2009 with a Hartal door, you will notice that the two bolts protruding on the door are inboard of the door edge so unlikely to be caught as you enter or exit. The images also show the type of exterior handle and the frame catch plate. Much more substantial than I have seen previously on caravans, even the German one I owned.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[fiferjim]

Suspected leaky hab door update.

First, apologies for the long post and I understand anyone not reading, but hope to have provided all detail so holes can be picked in my conclusions and possible solution!

Taking all the great advice, thank you, I visited the van to do more examination and try a few things. The hinges are fixed to the body and do adjust so no means to move door sideways or up and down, pic 1. The only adjustment is on the catch which governs the tightness of closed door and not only is it at its max, pic 2, the door has already to be slammed hard to get it to shut fully.

Given that there's a light of almost the same width as the hab door immediately above it and above that the awning which is sealed to the bodywork, pic 3, I don't think fitting a gutter channel would do much as the amount of water that could possibly run down on to hab door must be small.

I tried the 'paper test' by slamming the door shut on a sheet of paper and could reasonably easily pull/move the paper, the most difficult being at the bottom of the door (no doubt because of the metal protector strip). Interestingly the same test on the cab doors gave the same result. Another suggestion was to spray Teflon on the rubber seals. I only had silicon spray and it made no difference to the paper test. Can't see why Teflon would be any different?

Having had to take water with me I was limited to the amount available to spray and I was on my own. After spraying I went inside (through a cab door) to find that water had seemingly got in at the top of the door, pic 4 (sorry, no water visible in photo). Of course, water running down the inside of the door cannot escape at the bottom and so will inevitably spill on to the floor and also be soaked up by the wall which I believe is what has happened over several years.

With calipers I measured the gap between the door and the frame from the outside, pic 5. The opening has a slight taper such that the gap will be a bit less on the inside. I tried fitting self adhesive foam draught strip to the top of the seal that is around the opening, pic 6. It certainly gave a far better result for the paper test.

Given the variation in the gap and the taper I think the best solution is to fit self adhesive brush strip to the opening along the top, if not on 3 sides, such that as the door closes it moves against and under the brush pile. Fitting it to the door would be much easier as it has a nice channel to follow, pic 7, but any water along the top of the door will tend to go into the brush material. Reading reviews for brush strip it seems adhesive often fails very soon. Does anyone know of any very sticky brush strip and more importantly, do you think my conclusion/solution is sound?

Cheers!

 

[bigalw35]

Yes 2006 model 680 , must have done a modification to original specification.
It only screws over the top of the existing fitting perhaps you could get it from Brownhills at Newark ask Darren he would know.

Hi KUSKUS, spoke to Darren both ordered, should be here in a couple of days, many thanks

 

[bigalw35]

Hi KUSKUS, door covers arrived today, very nice, driver side fitted already, PERFECT, many thanks, passenger side going on tomorrow
POST SCRIPT.
If we bump into each other at a meet, the beers, schnapps or brandies are on me, cheers AL

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Skyway]

Does the awning and very close to the hab door

 

[bigalw35]

Does the awning and very close to the hab door

???

 

[Skyway]

Sorry does it end and water runs down off it and runs down side of hab door

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Northernraider]

We also own a Hymer b 680 but ours have spring covers to stop you catching yourselves on it.

As does my 2004 hymer

 

[bigalw35]

As does my 2004 hymer

as does mine too NOW, thanks to KUSKUS, pics will follow later today

 

[RobL]

I have the same problem with my Knaus. No water ingress just draughts. I would be tempted to fit a larger seal if available. I have used this company before. https://www.sealsdirect.co.uk

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[bigalw35]

I have the same problem with my Knaus. No water ingress just draughts. I would be tempted to fit a larger seal if available. I have used this company before. https://www.sealsdirect.co.uk

doesn't matter now, but I've saved the site info, I needed some sort of seal for my roof lights, no leaks, just a load of crap (leaves and dirt etc) my roof lights have two seals inner and outer, the outer seal was not there

 

[Clive Beeza]

I have the same problem with my Knaus. No water ingress just draughts. I would be tempted to fit a larger seal if available. I have used this company before. https://www.sealsdirect.co.uk

Have also used different profile /sizes of seals from this supplier and are very helpful, get their catalogue which gives exact sized images and will supply a short length FOC for you to double check suitability before placing your full order, all sorts of seals rubber solid and hollow sponge foam self adhesive etc etc
well worth having their catalogue book for future reference,

 

[dannymac]

Hi Fiferjim You can get it from the FIAMMA accessory store its called drip stop.
Regards
dannymac

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[bigalw35]

as does mine too NOW, thanks to KUSKUS, pics will follow later today

pics as promised, the driver side was a direct replacement, but the passenger side was slightly different as there a "U" shaped piece of metal around the bolt, so I had to take that off and re-align the bolt, all done and sweet, jobs a gudun

driver side

passenger side

 

[bigalw35]

although I've now cured my Hymer door flaw (thanks KUSKUS) I still think that the bolt on the body is a design flaw, most other vehicles have the bolt on the door