Water Tank - Baffles Or Not? (1 Viewer)

[Stealaway]

Is that a stability or a weight issue??

I'm sure it will be a weight issue as there is so little spare payload on modern vans.
I'm guessing but as the tank is so low it won't cause a problem with handling.
The Burstner tank doesn't have baffles but it's a strange shape and maybe it automatically baffles the water

 

[HKF]

Is that a stability or a weight issue??

Or it could be that it's a thinner tank, as Jim mentioned in his article, and liable to damage. That's what's on my mind.

 

[Spriddler]

I don't understand your point. I'm trying to determine whether or not I have a suitable tank to cope with water sloshing around in it. If it's not suitable, I can mitigate any issues by not carrying water in it (or carrying very little).

You worry too much.
Just try it to see if there are any issues.
I've read similar posts on here from the Worried Well (usually newcomers to motorhomes) but I don't recall anyone reporting a problem.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Otter Spotter]

When buying stuff for my van CAK tanks confirmed no baffles in their tanks, not sure if it’s relevant to HKF

 

[HKF]

You worry too much.
Just try it to see if there are any issues.
I've read similar posts on here from the Worried Well (usually newcomers to motorhomes) but I don't recall anyone reporting a problem.

I worry because I like to be proactive rather than reactive. Your suggestion to 'try it to see if there are any issues' doesn't sit well in my world. So, I try it and the tank bursts because a cheaper and thinner tank has been used to justify extra payload for the manufacturer. So, then I'm sat with a burst tank. Who's the winner there?? I'd rather mitigate that issue by finding out if it's a cheaper, thinner tank to start with and, therefore, travel with it empty and not have it burst at all.

 

[Jimbohorlicks]

When the motoh9me manual says not to travel with a full water tank and only 20 litrs or so its primarily to keep the weight of the van down below 3500kg be cause so many Van's are advertised now as 3500 but they dont allow for very much payload. Plastic tanks are plastic tanks and ate not usually made thin for weight reduction. I have never heard of a water tank busting due to sloshing about or filling it full.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[tonyidle]

Our van has a 230 litre tank, running transversely. Tall and narrow to fit but no baffles or issues either

As had mine. I've turned the tank through 90 degrees (nothing to do with the tank itself). No issues before or since.

 

[Otter Spotter]

I worry because I like to be proactive rather than reactive. Your suggestion to 'try it to see if there are any issues' doesn't sit well in my world. So, I try it and the tank bursts because a cheaper and thinner tank has been used to justify extra payload for the manufacturer. So, then I'm sat with a burst tank. Who's the winner there?? I'd rather mitigate that issue by finding out if it's a cheaper, thinner tank to start with and, therefore, travel with it empty and not have it burst at all.

Have you ever heard of anyones watertank bursting?

 

[Jim]

Have you ever heard of anyones watertank bursting?

No. But who knows what they are fitting now. They will do anything to save weight, like sell you a £70k van with just one 70AH lead acid battery within.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Otter Spotter]

No. But who knows what they are fitting now. They will do anything to save weight, like sell you a £70k van with just one 70AH lead acid battery within.

Is that to save weight or money for them? I am always amazed at the crap fixtures and fittings the big constructors use in vans, plastic hinges, taps made in plastic and chromed to look like metal with crappy nylon joints that wear out with a couple of years etc etc.

 

[DuxDeluxe]

As had mine. I've turned the tank through 90 degrees (nothing to do with the tank itself). No issues before or since.

I have the transverse double over the garage and the tank sits across the forward bulkhead of the garage

 

[tonyidle]

I have the transverse double over the garage and the tank sits across the forward bulkhead of the garage

Mine's in the same place. I've turned it to make room for an electrics panel in front of the tank instead of to one side of it next to the battery.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[HKF]

Have you ever heard of anyones watertank bursting?

No, but then I'm new to MoHo-ing so doesn't really prove anything.

 

[HKF]

JJ Welcome to my Ignore List

 

[poppycamper]

No, but then I'm new to MoHo-ing so doesn't really prove anything.

As you say new to motorhoming and you have your concerns.
However the more experienced Funsters are only trying to put your mind at rest so you are better abled to actually njoy your van.
I am sure no malice is intended by anyone.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[cmcardle75]

Don’t worry too much. You could start a poll Have you ever had a water tank fail In normal use. Yes or No. I’d bet the yes column would be empty or as good as.

I have. A split near a fitting. Welded it back together using various bits of plastic waste and a soldering iron.

 

[carolyn]

I didn’t even know what baffles were so I’ve learnt something new today, always a good thing. Unfortunately I will now be wondering what bit of knowledge fell out to make room. I can understand HKF worrying after a run of things going wrong , it knocks your confidence. Sarky comments don’t help at all as you sort of know you might be over planning and looking for every possible problem but for some of us it helps until you’ve had a run of things going smoothly and got your confidence back. Fortunately most Funsters are very helpful indeed.

 

[cmcardle75]

I didn’t even know what baffles were so I’ve learnt something new today, always a good thing. Unfortunately I will now be wondering what bit of knowledge fell out to make room. I can understand HKF worrying after a run of things going wrong , it knocks your confidence. Sarky comments don’t help at all as you sort of know you might be over planning and looking for every possible problem but for some of us it helps until you’ve had a run of things going smoothly and got your confidence back. Fortunately most Funsters are very helpful indeed.

My 210 litre tank is baffled. I thought that was large enough to be worth specifying, especially as I often run it half full (210 litres is too much for a weekend and I don't want to waste any).

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[DuxDeluxe]

I didn’t even know what baffles were so I’ve learnt something new today, always a good thing. Unfortunately I will now be wondering what bit of knowledge fell out to make room. I can understand HKF worrying after a run of things going wrong , it knocks your confidence. Sarky comments don’t help at all as you sort of know you might be over planning and looking for every possible problem but for some of us it helps until you’ve had a run of things going smoothly and got your confidence back. Fortunately most Funsters are very helpful indeed.

Quite agree, Carolyn - sneering replies are just totally unnecessary when a genuine question is asked

 

[DuxDeluxe]

My 210 litre tank is baffled. I thought that was large enough to be worth specifying, especially as I often run it half full (210 litres is too much for a weekend and I don't want to waste any).

What actual shape is it? Tall and long or a fat underslung type?

 

[Otter Spotter]

What actual shape is it? Tall and long or a fat underslung type?

210 ltrs, it must be a water bed shape

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[cmcardle75]

What actual shape is it? Tall and long or a fat underslung type?

It is tall and long, but not particularly wide. It is onboard, as is the grey tank, as I wanted something pretty winterised. The shower has an underslung sump with a bilge pump into the onboard grey tank. The grey is only about 65 litres, as it is much easier to get rid of grey water than fill fresh. It fits underneath the bed, matching height of the CRX80 fridge.

210 Litre Upright Baffled Water Tank - Online Tank Store

210 Litre Upright Baffled Water Tank With 8" Lid & 3/4″ BSP Outlet. WRAS Approved Polyethylene Polymer. Baffled For Strength & Stability. UK-Manufactured.

www.onlinetankstore.co.uk

65 Litre Water Tank - Online Tank Store

65 Litre Water Tank with a 5" Internal Plain Lid & a 3/4″ Outlet. . Quality Products at Competitive Prices. UK Manufactured

www.onlinetankstore.co.uk

 

[cmcardle75]

210 ltrs, it must be a water bed shape

I wish. I have to make do with a standard domestic pocket sprung mattress!

 

[MartinandBev]

Our Adria does but anything below half full and they are pointless as I found out on a recent road trip

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[BouncyBoatFolk]

Was the same advice also issued in respect of grey, and black tanks ? It's all moving at the same velocity.
Mike.

 

[Bobbydaisy]

Don’t worry too much. You could start a poll Have you ever had a water tank fail In normal use. Yes or No. I’d bet the yes column would be empty or as good as.

If in the yes column ….it wasn’t just the column that was empty

 

[dorkins]

Why not just contact Benimar? I am sure that faced with the question "is it safety/handling or a potential weight issue" you would get a definitive answer, worth an email!

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}