What do our experts think of this of this?

Asfaics using busbars with individual MBRF fuses seems a little over the top to me, as long as you have a suitable MBRF on the battery posts then why should you not use a megafuse distribution board for the individual runs?
 
Asfaics using busbars with individual MBRF fuses seems a little over the top to me, as long as you have a suitable MBRF on the battery posts then why should you not use a megafuse distribution board for the individual runs?
None that I can see.

Ian
 
When do I renew my leisure battery??? 21 plate so battery is 4 years old. Going to Spain in April for first time for an extended (10 week) wander around, don't know where yet, depends on weather. Had pre purchase check, all OK.
 
When do I renew my leisure battery??? 21 plate so battery is 4 years old. Going to Spain in April for first time for an extended (10 week) wander around, don't know where yet, depends on weather. Had pre purchase check, all OK.
How do you plan on using the van? Hook up ? Or wild camping? The latter favours, good battery's and some replenishing means, either solar or B2B. Some have been more than happy with a battery in a box type of scenario, but it still needs topping up by some means.
Mike.
 
Asfaics using busbars with individual MBRF fuses seems a little over the top to me, as long as you have a suitable MBRF on the battery posts then why should you not use a megafuse distribution board for the individual runs?
Absolutely.

The MRBF only needs to be on the battery (or each battery if more than one) purely because of the ICC it can handle, there would be no need for more of them on sub-circuits at all. Mega, midi or even blade fuses of the correct rating would be absolutely fine on these.
 
I often wonder how people classify themselves as 'Experts' ! We even have one or two funsters on here who are classified as experts by other Funsters. It would appear there is no formal qualification for this recognition and anybody can call themselves an expert. This may explain why there are so many experts who talk rubbish.
 
I often wonder how people classify themselves as 'Experts' ! We even have one or two funsters on here who are classified as experts by other Funsters. It would appear there is no formal qualification for this recognition and anybody can call themselves an expert. This may explain why there are so many experts who talk rubbish.
I don't think anyone on this thread has claimed to be an "expert" or been hailed as one.

Personally I have been a mechanical/electrical engineer for 42 years, am the MD of my own engineering consultancy practice, am a member of the Institute of Engineering & Technology (MIET) and would I consider myself an "expert" in this field? No, absulutely not. However, would I consider myself in a position to offer reasoned advice, or suggest resources such as the IET or IEEE? Yes I would think so.

I agree that there is some eyewateringly poor information presented on these forums, some of which is downright dangerous, but what I've read on this thread so far appears to be reasonable and, in the main, sensible for the right reasons.
 
I don't think anyone on this thread has claimed to be an "expert" or been hailed as one.

Personally I have been a mechanical/electrical engineer for 42 years, am the MD of my own engineering consultancy practice, am a member of the Institute of Engineering & Technology (MIET) and would I consider myself an "expert" in this field? No, absulutely not. However, would I consider myself in a position to offer reasoned advice, or suggest resources such as the IET or IEEE? Yes I would think so.

I agree that there is some eyewateringly poor information presented on these forums, some of which is downright dangerous, but what I've read on this thread so far appears to be reasonable and, in the main, sensible for the right reasons.
I agree with much of what you have said. I too have seen content on fun that is at best misleading and in some cases dangerous, all probably with good intent. As an aside, I never claimed that anyone in this thread was claiming to be an expert. My post was a generalisation about people calling themselves or others experts.
 
I often wonder how people classify themselves as 'Experts' ! We even have one or two funsters on here who are classified as experts by other Funsters. It would appear there is no formal qualification for this recognition and anybody can call themselves an expert. This may explain why there are so many experts who talk rubbish.
It's all relative. I once helped a couple of absolute beginners who had just hired a motorhome, and hadn't been shown how to open the locked water filler cap. To them I was an expert. Could I design and build a complete motorhome water system? Probably, but I'm no expert. And as for fault-finding, that's an art in itself.
 
I often wonder how people classify themselves as 'Experts' ! We even have one or two funsters on here who are classified as experts by other Funsters. It would appear there is no formal qualification for this recognition and anybody can call themselves an expert. This may explain why there are so many experts who talk rubbish.
I don't recall anyone calling themselves an expert. I prefer experience over qualifications though.

I am a qualified electronics engineer and did my Electrical apprenticeship back in the late 80s early 90s. But I haven't practised since 1994 so my knowledge is out of date and fading rapidly since I hit my 50s.
That is why I refer to Raul so much who does this stuff for a living and really does know his stuff on this subject.

On certain sections of IT I am a specialist but I wouldn't call myself an expert by any means of the word. I have been doing server side and security stuff for 30 years and programming for a lot longer. But even with that experience I don't call myself an expert.

My posts in this thread are to clarify my own thinking on the subject and understand it better for my own purposes.
 
Agreed.

I think (hope) people quickly establish which members they value certain information from in certain forums, such as Basildog on gas. I know I have a few whose advice/input I value greatly on electrical/battery items, such as Raul and autorouter, as they very clearly have expertise in this particular field, not just picked up some snippets as they've gone along (which can of course be useful in its own right).

What I find quite difficult, and maybe this is the case for others, is presenting useful information in a short post in such a way as it is almost 'dumbed down' (I don't mean that in a demeaning or patronising way to anyone) to the extent that it is non technical and simplified so it can be understood and absorbed and not mistaken. During years of tutoring when running a testing department in a previous life I learnt that simplifying technical issues is difficult but infinitely useful, hence the huge success of the "For Dummies" series of publications. I actually have my own YouTube channel called Simplified Astro, which I've not posted on for some time for various reasons, which adopts this exact ethos in relation to another passion of mine, astrophotography, which can be an incredibly complex subject which people struggle to understand unless explained in a way which is understandable to those without the technical knowledge.
 
What I find quite difficult, and maybe this is the case for others, is presenting useful information in a short post in such a way as it is almost 'dumbed down' (I don't mean that in a demeaning or patronising way to anyone) to the extent that it is non technical and simplified so it can be understood and absorbed and not mistaken. During years of tutoring when running a testing department in a previous life I learnt that simplifying technical issues is difficult but infinitely useful, hence the huge success of the "For Dummies" series of publications. I actually have my own YouTube channel called Simplified Astro, which I've not posted on for some time for various reasons, which adopts this exact ethos in relation to another passion of mine, astrophotography, which can be an incredibly complex subject which people struggle to understand unless explained in a way which is understandable to those without the technical knowledge.
That's true, if you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough, as Albert Einstein said.
 
That's true, if you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough, as Albert Einstein said.
I often learn a lot while trying to explain something.

I had a very large contract some years ago writing technical tutorials for the linux system. I was competent on the command line before that, but it raised my levels of understanding massively.
Teaching/explaining stuff is a very good way to deepen your understanding of a subject.
 
That breaker I suggested for MisterB is for a house battery 48v. He has a Seplos 48v. It will be an overkill for 12v applications, it will do the job, but it's just too big in the van, 2pole 3 modules.
You may want a smaller classT or even a MRBF for a smaller battery.
I have 700ah too much for an MRBF, and went with 10kA DC breakers from Outback. I could have fitted a classT, but, I have 3 batteries in parallel, and each has a breaker on it, that can be used as isolators. MRBF directly on the battery terminal is a good solution too.
I use an mrbf on the battery terminal. Actually have a dual mrbf. One for an inverter (if I ever get around to fitting one) and one appropriately sized for the rest of them/h.
 
Very interesting thread and jam packed with good information but …….

I’m not sure I trust my own calculations 100% and would like to ask for advice on this imminent upgrade I’m about to undertake.

Currently in the Ducato base Adria as a factory fit I have 2x 100Ah NDS Green Power AGMs under the passenger seat feeding the electrical ‘gubbins’ (already Lithium compatible) in the cupboard under the dinette bench seat approx 1.5m away. I want to replace them with a single Fogstar Drift PRO 300Ah and also install a 3000w NDS Inverter under the driver’s seat base. So a few Qs:

1) What cable sizes from battery to inverter - approximately 1.5m run?

2) Will I need to up the size of the existing battery to electrics cables to accommodate the lithium/extra 100Ah?

3) What size MRBF on the battery to inverter? Is it advised to install another for the battery to existing electrics and if so, same size? Can’t see there being any room available for a busbar type arrangement as it’ll be really tight as is.

4) Anything else to consider?

TIA
 
Very interesting thread and jam packed with good information but …….

I’m not sure I trust my own calculations 100% and would like to ask for advice on this imminent upgrade I’m about to undertake.

Currently in the Ducato base Adria as a factory fit I have 2x 100Ah NDS Green Power AGMs under the passenger seat feeding the electrical ‘gubbins’ (already Lithium compatible) in the cupboard under the dinette bench seat approx 1.5m away. I want to replace them with a single Fogstar Drift PRO 300Ah and also install a 3000w NDS Inverter under the driver’s seat base. So a few Qs:

1) What cable sizes from battery to inverter - approximately 1.5m run?

2) Will I need to up the size of the existing battery to electrics cables to accommodate the lithium/extra 100Ah?

3) What size MRBF on the battery to inverter? Is it advised to install another for the battery to existing electrics and if so, same size? Can’t see there being any room available for a busbar type arrangement as it’ll be really tight as is.

4) Anything else to consider?

TIA

Bump.

Raul Lenny HB ….anyone?
 
Very interesting thread and jam packed with good information but …….

I’m not sure I trust my own calculations 100% and would like to ask for advice on this imminent upgrade I’m about to undertake.

Currently in the Ducato base Adria as a factory fit I have 2x 100Ah NDS Green Power AGMs under the passenger seat feeding the electrical ‘gubbins’ (already Lithium compatible) in the cupboard under the dinette bench seat approx 1.5m away. I want to replace them with a single Fogstar Drift PRO 300Ah and also install a 3000w NDS Inverter under the driver’s seat base. So a few Qs:

1) What cable sizes from battery to inverter - approximately 1.5m run?

2) Will I need to up the size of the existing battery to electrics cables to accommodate the lithium/extra 100Ah?

3) What size MRBF on the battery to inverter? Is it advised to install another for the battery to existing electrics and if so, same size? Can’t see there being any room available for a busbar type arrangement as it’ll be really tight as is.

4) Anything else to consider?

TIA
Battery to inverter 50mm², 300 amp fuse but if you are never going to run the inverter at full power I would reduce the fuse size to 250 or 200 depending on what your maximum load is likely to be.

Cable size for rest of the electrics will depend on length of run & power drawn but assuming not more that a few metres 16mm² with 50 amp fuse.
 
1) What cable sizes from battery to inverter - approximately 1.5m run?

2) Will I need to up the size of the existing battery to electrics cables to accommodate the lithium/extra 100Ah?
As Lenny HB says, 50mm² is OK. I would go one size up, maybe 70mm², if you are buying new cable and don't have a stock of 50mm².

The existing electrics won't be drawing any more power than before, so no need to increase the cable size. The lithium battery with extra 100Ah capacity just means the power will last about twice as long.
 
I will add to the already good answers;
The inverter to battery ratio is too big.
You want a 50% max draw as in 300ah battery, a 150A max draw, that makes it a 2000VA inverter for. 300Ah battery.
 

Join us or log in to post a reply.

To join in you must be a member of MotorhomeFun

Join MotorhomeFun

Join us, it quick and easy!

Log in

Already a member? Log in here.

Forum posts reflect the views of individual users and not MotorhomeFun.
MotorhomeFun does not endorse or verify user-generated content.

Back
Top