Fiamma A20 Accumulator *causing* cycling?

cmcardle75

LIFE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Posts
2,666
Likes collected
3,447
Location
Reading
Funster No
21,386
MH
Riot Van Conversion
Exp
Since 2012
I'm just building a new Movano PVC. I specced up a Shurflo 2.1 bar pump and a Fiamma A20 accumulator from the start. However, on first test (only the wash basin taps available yet), there was extremely rapid (i.e twice per second) cycling from the pump, even at full flow. Even after turning the tap off, there would be a couple more cycles as it built up pressure.

After a bit more testing (i.e. just using a free flow hose as the only output), it became clear that with the accumulator removed, the pump would only cycle below a certain flow rate, controlled by sticking a finger on the end of the hose. However, with the A20 installed, it would ALWAYS rapid cycle, even with the hose unrestricted. After finding this, I bypassed the A20 in the system and the basin tap now works without cycling, provided you open it at least halfway. The pump now also turns off immediately the tap is closed, rather than having another 3 or 4 bursts.

Is the A20 faulty? I'd like to have the benefit of an accumulator to allow taps to be partially open. It's almost like it is acting like a big air bubble, causing rapid changes in pressure, rather than as an accumulator, absorbing changes. I tried changing orientation to release any trapped air, but there was no effect. The preload pressure was checked and a few different pressures attempted.
 
I considered fitting an accumulator but didn't. I have experience of pumped systems with solid displacement pumps and reckoned the water system was big enough not to require one.
 
I considered fitting an accumulator but didn't. I have experience of pumped systems with solid displacement pumps and reckoned the water system was big enough not to require one.

It could really use one, though. The flow rate through the basin tap would ideally be half what is required now as minimum. But I wanted higher flow for the sink and shower. The system is mostly 1/2" hose, so should be a little stretchy. I guess it will improve once the hot water system is in and a few extra metres of hose for the kitchen can't hurt.

But has anyone heard of an accumulator making cycling actually worse?
 

Join us or log in to post a reply.

To join in you must be a member of MotorhomeFun

Join MotorhomeFun

Join us, it quick and easy!

Log in

Already a member? Log in here.

Latest journal entries

Back
Top