Cam belt replacement Ducato 2.3 130bhp

[Petros]

I just in the throws of replacing the cam belt on my motorhome it is 5 years old. Most people replace the water pump at the same time, i am led to believe this is the right thing to do. Having read an article in the Feb issue (2020) of the MMM magazine which states that there is no need to replace the water pump unless there is damage or a leak to it. The article suggests that the water pump should probably last the life of the engine. I am totally confused.
Any thoughts on this

 

[Mr Colpot]

The Mechanics/Garages I asked were saying they would change the water pump as well as it would cost the same labour again to replace it if it failed.
One Fiat Garage said belt didnt need changing until 7 years but I checked with Fiat themselves and they said 5 years.

 

[David and Sally]

+1 on that

 

[Hettie's Crew]

The Fiat Professional garage I used were just going to replace the belts but double checked with Fiat. Fiat said the full kit, including tensioner, pump and pulleys should all be replaced at 5 years regardless of mileage.
The Genuine Fiat kit was £360 plus vat.

 

[pappajohn]

The Fiat Professional garage I used were just going to replace the belts but double checked with Fiat. Fiat said the full kit, including tensioner, pump and pulleys should all be replaced at 5 years regardless of mileage.
The Genuine Fiat kit was £360 plus vat.

I wouldn't be going back there again.

One Fiat Garage said belt didnt need changing until 7 years but I checked with Fiat themselves and they said 5 years

Or there...
Always fit a full kit and being fiat 'professional'(?) they should know that.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Ernesto]

Quick search found this ...

Water pump + timing belt kit for FIAT Ducato III Van (250, 290) 150 Multijet 2,3 D from 06.2011, 148 HP

If its the right kit (??), prices from £99 inc VAT and the water pump, and including branded options from Bosch at £162 inc VAT


Broken Link Removed

 

[Petros]

Quick search found this ...

Water pump + timing belt kit for FIAT Ducato III Van (250, 290) 150 Multijet 2,3 D from 06.2011, 148 HP

If its the right kit (??), prices from £99 inc VAT and the water pump, and including branded options from Bosch at £162 inc VAT


Broken Link Removed

 

[Petros]

Thanks for all the replies, I reckon best to replace all components.