Parallel battery conflicting advice. (1 Viewer)

Emmenay

Free Member
Dec 11, 2011
505
481
Funster No
19,163
MH
Swift Kon-tiki 600
Exp
Since 2011
Regarding three leisure batteries in parallel, can some knowledgable folk cast their eye over the below statement and kindly offer their opinion.
It seems quite feasible to me but seems to go against the status quo of connecting solar etc at opposite ends...



Parallel connections involve connecting the POSITIVE (+) connection of one battery to the POSITIVE (+) connection of the next battery. The same goes for the negative side; NEGATIVE (-) of the first battery connects to the NEGATIVE (-) of the next battery. You can connect the POSITIVE (+) of your charge controller and/or DC-to-AC inverter to any POSITIVE (+) point in the battery bank, though it is best to make this connection in the middle of the set of batteries rather than from one end (as shown). Same goes for the negative side; connect the NEGATIVE (-) of your charge controller and/or DC-to-AC inverter to any NEGATIVE (-) point in the battery bank, though a point in the middle is best.

By making the system connection in the middle of the battery bank, the charging and discharging cycles are done in a balanced way. If the system connections are made on the ends, then more charge will flow into the first battery and less flow into the last battery. When discharging, the first battery will discharge first and the last battery in line will discharge last. This is not good for the life of a battery bank
 
Jan 19, 2014
9,322
24,581
Derbyshire
Funster No
29,757
MH
Elddis Accordo 105
Exp
since 2014
The last sentence is correct. But If you connect the positive to one end and negative to the opposite end it's balanced though.

By connecting to the middle battery for both + and - it means the middle battery will get slightly more charge /discharge. Probably won't make much difference in use anyway.
 

andy63

Free Member
Jan 19, 2014
4,672
15,017
south shields
Funster No
29,767
MH
None
Exp
since 1990
OP
OP
Emmenay

Emmenay

Free Member
Dec 11, 2011
505
481
Funster No
19,163
MH
Swift Kon-tiki 600
Exp
Since 2011
I've had three in parallel for a couple of years now with the solar wires connected diagonally opposite and the hab power connected to the other diagonal opposite.
What I have found is the battery with the solar live wire is needing regular topping up as it seems to be doing all of the work, while the opposite end battery which is first in line to supply hab power always seems to struggle according to the on board control unit.
Looking at the theory of connecting to the centre battery with two 'outrigger' batteries does seem to me like a more balanced balance so to speak.
 
R

Robert Clark

Deleted User
If space allows I’d install two small bus bars and connect each battery to the bus bars with equal length cables
 
Oct 8, 2014
1,614
2,961
Wiltshire
Funster No
33,737
MH
Autotrail Excel 600B
Exp
Previous VW Camper + Caravan
If space allows I’d install two small bus bars and connect each battery to the bus bars with equal length cables
I agree. That's "Method 3" in the earlier link.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 

eddie

LIFE MEMBER
Oct 4, 2007
8,131
41,040
Taunton Somerset
Funster No
540
MH
RV
Exp
since 1989
Regarding three leisure batteries in parallel, can some knowledgable folk cast their eye over the below statement and kindly offer their opinion.
It seems quite feasible to me but seems to go against the status quo of connecting solar etc at opposite ends...



Parallel connections involve connecting the POSITIVE (+) connection of one battery to the POSITIVE (+) connection of the next battery. The same goes for the negative side; NEGATIVE (-) of the first battery connects to the NEGATIVE (-) of the next battery. You can connect the POSITIVE (+) of your charge controller and/or DC-to-AC inverter to any POSITIVE (+) point in the battery bank, though it is best to make this connection in the middle of the set of batteries rather than from one end (as shown). Same goes for the negative side; connect the NEGATIVE (-) of your charge controller and/or DC-to-AC inverter to any NEGATIVE (-) point in the battery bank, though a point in the middle is best.

By making the system connection in the middle of the battery bank, the charging and discharging cycles are done in a balanced way. If the system connections are made on the ends, then more charge will flow into the first battery and less flow into the last battery. When discharging, the first battery will discharge first and the last battery in line will discharge last. This is not good for the life of a battery bank
What is this source please?
 

eddie

LIFE MEMBER
Oct 4, 2007
8,131
41,040
Taunton Somerset
Funster No
540
MH
RV
Exp
since 1989
Unfortunately not, I have one under each front seat and one behind the front seat under the bench seat .

Ah I see, re-reading your post, I can see where your getting confused.

Your quote refers to "battery bank" and this is a picture of a "bank" from their website
1611584834852.png

Which I am assuming is a couple more batteries than you intend to install?

This picture, again from their web site is the correct way to install small numbers of batteries in parallel
(unless you are installing Lithium Batteries and your installing a largish inverter)
1611584982456.png

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
OP
OP
Emmenay

Emmenay

Free Member
Dec 11, 2011
505
481
Funster No
19,163
MH
Swift Kon-tiki 600
Exp
Since 2011
I think the large bank picture is not referring to the parallel scenario as quoted in my original post, as it is a serial/parallel setup.
Below is the large bank picture with its description.
I always thought more than one battery is a bank of batteries but I stand corrected.
Are we saying that connection to the middle battery is no good or just not the done thing, I'm none the wiser right now :cautious:

Series/Parallel connections​

In some cases, several batteries need to be connected in a series set to achieve the desired system voltage, and then placed in parallel with an identical serial set. This is very typical when 6-volt batteries are used. Much like in the parallel-only case, the connection to the system is ideally done at the center of the battery bank so that charging and discharging is done in a balanced way.

Large battery banks​

battery_config_fig2wn.jpg


Shown above is a typical 48V battery bank made up of a series/parallel connection of 6-volt batteries.
 

DBK

LIFE MEMBER
Jan 9, 2013
17,969
47,804
Plympton, Devon
Funster No
24,219
MH
PVC, Murvi Morocco
Exp
2013
I've had three in parallel for a couple of years now with the solar wires connected diagonally opposite and the hab power connected to the other diagonal opposite.
What I have found is the battery with the solar live wire is needing regular topping up as it seems to be doing all of the work, while the opposite end battery which is first in line to supply hab power always seems to struggle according to the on board control unit.
Looking at the theory of connecting to the centre battery with two 'outrigger' batteries does seem to me like a more balanced balance so to speak.
If I understand your description then the way they are wired is wrong. As a rule (and I can't see any reason why you would do it any other way) all charging connections should be attached to the same terminals the load is taken from. This allows any loads to draw current directly from the charging power without it having to pass through a battery. :)
 
OP
OP
Emmenay

Emmenay

Free Member
Dec 11, 2011
505
481
Funster No
19,163
MH
Swift Kon-tiki 600
Exp
Since 2011
If I understand your description then the way they are wired is wrong. As a rule (and I can't see any reason why you would do it any other way) all charging connections should be attached to the same terminals the load is taken from. This allows any loads to draw current directly from the charging power without it having to pass through a battery. :)
Quite possibly, maybe I didn't know better at the time but now I'm trying to educate myself :giggle:

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
  • Like
Reactions: DBK

DBK

LIFE MEMBER
Jan 9, 2013
17,969
47,804
Plympton, Devon
Funster No
24,219
MH
PVC, Murvi Morocco
Exp
2013
Quite possibly, maybe I didn't know better at the time but now I'm trying to educate myself :giggle:
It's not critical and will work fine. The small downside is one of the charging systems will have a slightly longer cable length to go pass through to reach the load. The extra length is the cable(s) linking the batteries together. If you connect at the load end the current can go directly to the load.
 
OP
OP
Emmenay

Emmenay

Free Member
Dec 11, 2011
505
481
Funster No
19,163
MH
Swift Kon-tiki 600
Exp
Since 2011
Dec 2, 2019
3,555
7,701
Amersham
Funster No
67,145
MH
van conversion
Exp
Since 2019
Regarding three leisure batteries in parallel, can some knowledgable folk cast their eye over the below statement and kindly offer their opinion.
It seems quite feasible to me but seems to go against the status quo of connecting solar etc at opposite ends...



Parallel connections involve connecting the POSITIVE (+) connection of one battery to the POSITIVE (+) connection of the next battery. The same goes for the negative side; NEGATIVE (-) of the first battery connects to the NEGATIVE (-) of the next battery. You can connect the POSITIVE (+) of your charge controller and/or DC-to-AC inverter to any POSITIVE (+) point in the battery bank, though it is best to make this connection in the middle of the set of batteries rather than from one end (as shown). Same goes for the negative side; connect the NEGATIVE (-) of your charge controller and/or DC-to-AC inverter to any NEGATIVE (-) point in the battery bank, though a point in the middle is best.

By making the system connection in the middle of the battery bank, the charging and discharging cycles are done in a balanced way. If the system connections are made on the ends, then more charge will flow into the first battery and less flow into the last battery. When discharging, the first battery will discharge first and the last battery in line will discharge last. This is not good for the life of a battery bank
This explanation is correct and it means the connection is made in the middle of the link between the two batteries, half way each way. It replicates exactly as you would have a buss bar like in the link on smart gauge option 3. That is the most balanced.
The opposite ends will work very well to, and if I would of been in this situation, that’s how I would wire it if buss bar was not possible. Buss bar allows for individual battery fuse as well.
 
OP
OP
Emmenay

Emmenay

Free Member
Dec 11, 2011
505
481
Funster No
19,163
MH
Swift Kon-tiki 600
Exp
Since 2011
So in conclusion, its anybody best guess, I think maybe now I concur with pappajohn .
I think I'm going to try the middle option to see how things pan out, damn I might even mix it up a little and put a bigger battery in the middle (call the police) to cope with the stress of it all, maybe that might give my control unit more accurate readings?

It seems that the subject is, well, subjective, and perhaps fits the same category as say, 'which is the best brand of battery or, what is the best adhesive or, to A-frame or not to A-frame amongst many many others :unsure: :winky:
 

andy63

Free Member
Jan 19, 2014
4,672
15,017
south shields
Funster No
29,767
MH
None
Exp
since 1990
So in conclusion, its anybody best guess
Not at all..
I dont think you have grasped what's been posted..
There is a way of wiring the 3 batteries which ensures that the load and charging current are shared equally... subject to the battery internal resistances been the same.. that is to connect each battery with equal length wires to a common point ...
Alternatively.. use the other set up (picture posted by Eddie above ) which according to the figures quoted in the link I posted does give a reasonably balanced distribution and is acceptable in most cases..
Your distribution of batteries isn't ideal in either case and will involve longer runs to make the connections..
In both cases the load and any charging sources should be taken from the same points on the bank..
I dont see any grey areas in those explanations..
Andy

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
OP
OP
Emmenay

Emmenay

Free Member
Dec 11, 2011
505
481
Funster No
19,163
MH
Swift Kon-tiki 600
Exp
Since 2011
Not at all..
I dont think you have grasped what's been posted..
There is a way of wiring the 3 batteries which ensures that the load and charging current are shared equally... subject to the battery internal resistances been the same.. that is to connect each battery with equal length wires to a common point ...
Alternatively.. use the other set up (picture posted by Eddie above ) which according to the figures quoted in the link I posted does give a reasonably balanced distribution and is acceptable in most cases..
Your distribution of batteries isn't ideal in either case and will involve longer runs to make the connections..
In both cases the load and any charging sources should be taken from the same points on the bank..
I dont see any grey areas in those explanations..
Andy
Thats very clear, thank you.
 

Join us or log in to post a reply.

To join in you must be a member of MotorhomeFun

Join MotorhomeFun

Join us, it quick and easy!

Log in

Already a member? Log in here.

Latest journal entries

Funsters who are viewing this thread

Back
Top