Citroen Relay 70 plate - how to permanently turn off Start/Stop?

Joined
Sep 5, 2024
Posts
2,651
Likes collected
7,732
Location
In a tin box
Funster No
106,205
MH
Building a PVC
I know it's possible because I've had the van a couple of years and it's never had the Start/Stop.

I changed the battery, and like a fool forgot to do the masonic ritual of disconnection sequence.

New battery has gone in fine and everything is working as expected so I thought all was well with the world.

However, first drive today and the Start Stop has come to life.

Yes, I know I can push the button on the dash EVERY time I start the engine, but I didn't have to before and therefore I know there must be a way - but I don't know what that is.

Anyone know?
 
Can you wedge a small piece of plastic cut from an old bank card/cable tie or similar down the side of the button to keep it depressed? That's what I did with my wife's Picanto and it works a treat. If you leave it so a short bit of the wedge sticks out, you can always remove it if required. I programmed start/stop to default to being disabled on my Volvo, but can enable it by pressing the dash button at the start of or during a journey if I want to, so the exact opposite of normal operation. I don't know of any way to disable it by programming on the Ducato though, unless there is a suitable CanM8 or similar plug in device on the market?

It was probably disabled before due to the condition of the old battery. You might find before too long it stops working again, judging by the number of people on various forums who complain that their stop/start isn't working and want to fix it!
 
My Fabia has a small cable connected to the neg battery terminal which isolates the Stop/Start when unplugged!
 
My Fabia has a small cable connected to the neg battery terminal which isolates the Stop/Start when unplugged!
That could be a wire from the shunt, to let the ECU know the state of the battery.

Geoff
 
That could be a wire from the shunt, to let the ECU know the state of the battery.

Geoff
Not sure about the wire source, but I alternate between using Stop/Start
and mainly isolating Stop/Start just to exercise its function.
 
On VW Transporters you can get a bit of electronics from ebay or Aliexpress that plugs into the back of the button.

Is there a dash button? There is probably a solution for your van.
 
I asked google AI.

"Citroen relay in uk on 70 plate: how to disable stop/start?"

It includes two 'solutions' mentioned already (above) as well as two others.

Google AI response here:
 
Was the stop start disabled before the new battery?
On my wife's car the stop start stopped working after a couple of years and when the battery was replaced a further 2yrs down the line it started working, it was nothing to do with the stop start but all to do with the battery voltage and certain conditions been met which could not be done with a battery that was not in tip top condition.
 
Was the stop start disabled before the new battery?
On my wife's car the stop start stopped working after a couple of years and when the battery was replaced a further 2yrs down the line it started working, it was nothing to do with the stop start but all to do with the battery voltage and certain conditions been met which could not be done with a battery that was not in tip top condition.
Weak battery disabling it would be my guess too. I don't think the manufacturer is allowed to provide a simple way to permanently disable it as it would affect the emissions for type approval.
 
Thanks all for the responses.

I suspect (but will never know) that it is just the new battery that's caused it to come back to life.

I'll try to live with manually turnig it off every time for a while and see how I get on.

I might even try living with it as a 'feature' for a while. I've never had it on a vehicle and might come to like it.

It was just unnerving when I wasn't expecting it.

I remain to be convinced that any of these 'driver aids' (aside from power steering, electric windows, central locking, ABS and cruise control) actually help the driver - compared to a 1970's transit van for example.
 
I'll try to live with manually turnig it off every time for a while and see how I get on.
That's what I do, annoying when you forget as the hill hold doesn't when the engine is stopped.

My last car it stopped working when the car was 18 months old , never did work again in the 13 years I had the car, it was still on the original battery.
 
That's absurd!

Oddly the hill assist is also something that freaks me out because I don't really know how it works so I just don't trust it.

I've managed on hills perfectly well for many years without it :D
 
What fascinates me is that the manufacturers state that when starting you wait for it to do all its checks & the lights to go out. So how can it restart instantly? My newish transit will not creep along in second gear on tickover. all it does is stall. When it does it will restart literally before the stall has finished.
 
What fascinates me is that the manufacturers state that when starting you wait for it to do all its checks & the lights to go out. So how can it restart instantly? My newish transit will not creep along in second gear on tickover. all it does is stall. When it does it will restart literally before the stall has finished.
Because it doesn't turn off the ignition it just stops the engine, so all the systems remain booted and ready.
 
Not sure about the wire source, but I alternate between using Stop/Start
and mainly isolating Stop/Start just to exercise its function.
I have the opposite problem on my 2021 Relay. Stop/start doesn’t work. I didn’t even know I had it until it kicked in unexpectedly and I thought I had broken down! It worked a couple of times more in that journey but since then nothing. Suggestions on how to make it work? ( Button on dash does show red light for on/off). On original battery.
 
The 2017> VW Crafter / MAN TGE has the added feature to Stop-Start in that the engine only stops if the brake pedal is pressed firmly, if you come to a halt with gentle pedal pressure and remain stationary without pressing harder the engine does not stop. It took me a while to realise that this happened but now accept it as a great feature.
 
My Fabia has a small cable connected to the neg battery terminal which isolates the Stop/Start when unplugged!
That's the battery monitoring module, if the other control modules don't know that the battery is fully (80%) charged they don't instruct the engine to stop.
 
That's the battery monitoring module, if the other control modules don't know that the battery is fully (80%) charged they don't instruct the engine to stop.
OK, that's interesting....

Are there any unintended consequences for locating and disconnecting this cable (assuming the Relay has one)?
 
I have the opposite problem on my 2021 Relay. Stop/start doesn’t work. I didn’t even know I had it until it kicked in unexpectedly and I thought I had broken down! It worked a couple of times more in that journey but since then nothing. Suggestions on how to make it work? ( Button on dash does show red light for on/off). On original battery.
Fit a new battery, the battery needs to be in really good condition for it to work. But if you fit a new battery it will need a proxy alignment, you can't just change a battery anymore.
 
On VW Transporters you can get a bit of electronics from ebay or Aliexpress that plugs into the back of the button.

Is there a dash button? There is probably a solution for your van.
Yes I bought same for my previous Transporter, and it worked well.
 
But if you fit a new battery it will need a proxy alignment, you can't just change a battery anymore.
Sorry, but what on earth is a proxy alignment?

I just changed the battery and that's why I've got this 'problem' of the start / stop working again.

If that's desirable, then just changing the battery seems to have worked just fine in my case.

Sadly, from my point of view, this is something I don't want :D
 
OK, that's interesting....

Are there any unintended consequences for locating and disconnecting this cable (assuming the Relay has one)?
That's a question that I wouldn't like to answer. The battery monitoring is there for various reasons, the obvious being that vehicles with Stop-Start do not charge the engine battery to 100% capacity thus leaving about 20% headroom to provide a small regenerative braking effect when desired which consequently can marginally reduce vehicle emissions. This of course is in addition to the actual Stop-Start system having the engine not producing exhaust emissions when not needed to be running.

Almost all of the vehicle control modules, and there are lots of them in a modern vehicle, are interconnected via one or more data buses so without a very deep knowledge of this data hierarchy and the associated module software it's not possible to say how having no battery monitoring effects the vehicle as a whole over an extended period of time.

I did say I wasn't willing to give a worthwhile answer.
 
Sorry, but what on earth is a proxy alignment?

I just changed the battery and that's why I've got this 'problem' of the start / stop working again.

If that's desirable, then just changing the battery seems to have worked just fine in my case.

Sadly, from my point of view, this is something I don't want :D
I have a solution for you. Let us swap batteries. I will take your nice shiny new one in exchange for my duff one and I won’t even charge you!😁
 
Looking at your rather nice photo in your avatar of a completed conversion and looking out of the window at my box van with no insulation in that I'm taking to the alps in a couple of month's time, I wondered if it might be less of a faff to just swap vehicles :D
 
OK, that's interesting....

Are there any unintended consequences for locating and disconnecting this cable (assuming the Relay has one)?
Haven't really dug into how the Stellantis BMS works , but if it is anything like new Fords, then besides S&S it'll take care of stuff like the smart charging but also for example battery protection, battery condition monitoring and load shedding. So if it detects too low voltages, the vehicle will begin to shed loads in priority order (external consumers via CCP in Ford will be first to go, s&s will go very easily, then stuff like AC and audio next, and finally safety critical items like power steering. We had faulty BMS in one Ford that destroyed the battery by overcharging so got to experience the step by step shut down of various systems first hand. First a year with just S&S affected and then the next winter begun all kinds of problems and until there was a recall for the faulty BMS' and got it sorted.
 
Looking at your rather nice photo in your avatar of a completed conversion and looking out of the window at my box van with no insulation in that I'm taking to the alps in a couple of month's time, I wondered if it might be less of a faff to just swap vehicles :D
Sorry. Turns out mine has a duff battery and needs its proxies aligned😀
 
I was amazed when I got my nearly new VW caddy the things that need to be in place before start/stop is activated.

    • Driver & Safety Status:
      • Driver is wearing their seat belt.
      • Driver's door is completely closed.
      • Bonnet (hood) is completely closed. [1]
    • Vehicle & Transmission State:
      • Manual transmission: The gear is in neutral and the clutch pedal is released.
      • Automatic (DSG) transmission: The vehicle is stationary and the brake pedal is pressed.
      • Steering wheel is straight (not turned sharply or being actively turned).
      • Reverse gear is not engaged.
      • Parking Assist or active park sensors/cameras are not turned on.
      • No trailer is electrically connected/hitched.
      • The vehicle is not on a steep hill or gradient. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
    • Engine & Climate Control:
      • Engine has reached its minimum operating temperature.
      • Interior cabin temperature is close to the preset climate control target, and humidity is not excessive.
      • Windscreen defrost/defog function or heavy windscreen heating is not switched on. [1, 2]
    • Battery & Electrical Load:
      • The 12-volt battery has a sufficient charge level and healthy voltage.
      • Battery temperature is within normal operating limits (not extremely hot or cold).
      • Electrical load from accessories (headlights, high heater/blower speeds, heated seats, or rear demister) is not too high. [1, 2, 3]
 

Join us or log in to post a reply.

To join in you must be a member of MotorhomeFun

Join MotorhomeFun

Join us, it quick and easy!

Log in

Already a member? Log in here.

Forum posts reflect the views of individual users and not MotorhomeFun.
MotorhomeFun does not endorse or verify user-generated content.

Back
Top