A TOWED CARS PRODUCT RECALL (1 Viewer)

[eddie]

Of course the law in the UK is different to the states

A-frames

www.gov.uk

 

[TonyEmm]

Are you working for this company by any chance....?!

I have never worked with ANY a-frame company, I’ve never built them either but, as a trailer manufacturer for 30ish years, and as I delivered training to the towing industry, allied to the fact that DfT insist TOADS have to comply with trailer regs, it should be no surprise that I know more than a little about them.

I make no apology for that, it is what it is.

 

[TonyEmm]

'Catastrophic' ?.............. One accident, 10 year old A frame, nobody injured?

....................Not even close!

............Much ado about nothing

..............One man's crusade...........

Maybe you’d think a little differently if it were you or yours that were confronted with a runaway car…. Just saying!

Why is folk won’t/can’t get their heads round the fact that this installation was illegal from the outset? The owner had no idea, until the thing failed and they came to depend on it.
It let them down, badly.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[TonyEmm]

It must be so frustrating to have all of the answers, know everyone is wrong, know that the Government Web site is wrong yet despite knowing all of this the damn things keep working!

Most will work, but some don’t!
It’s those we need to be concerned about….

 

[Barclaybasher]

Maybe you’d think a little differently if it were you or yours that were confronted with a runaway car…. Just saying!

Why is folk won’t/can’t get their heads round the fact that this installation was illegal from the outset? The owner had no idea, until the thing failed and they came to depend on it.
It let them down, badly.

Nobody was confronted by a runaway car.....

Nobody injured, you clearly have an agenda............ find something that is a real (and proven) danger to campaign about

 

[TonyEmm]

What Vehicles Make the Perfect RV Toad?

You may already have a good RV toad vehicle sitting in your garage or driveway, but if you don't here are a few smart options.

blog.campingworld.com

Totally irrelevant post. How many here pull a Jeep Wrangler or a Kia Sportage?
What they do in the States, is not at all relevant in the U.K. although it has to be said, they do have the better electronic activated systems!

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[TonyEmm]

Nobody was confronted by a runaway car.....

Nobody injured, you clearly have an agenda............ find something that is a real (and proven) danger to campaign about

You haven’t seen the witness statements, the owner said folk ran for their lives…. I said myself that no-one was injured! Luckily, it was a Sunday, the nearby school wasn’t open….. The other side of that fence BTW is a railway line…. Things could have been a LOT worse….

 

[eddie]

Totally irrelevant post. How many here pull a Jeep Wrangler or a Kia Sportage?
What they do in the States, is not at all relevant in the U.K. although it has to be said, they do have the better electronic activated systems!

I tow a 4x4 and I posted it to show how huge the A Frame market in the States is.

Also, given the America willingness to sue each other, if A-Frames were any where near as dangerous as you keep telling us, the A-Frame manufacturers would have been out of business years ago

Instead there are hundreds of thousands of A-Framed cars towed in the States, but I agree it doesn’t suit your narrative so you’d consider my post irrelevant

 

[TonyEmm]

Of course the law in the UK is different to the states

A-frames

www.gov.uk

So why post irrelevant stuff from the States? And the page you refer to isn’t the law, it’s an advice page, written by the IVS division of the DfT.

The relevant law is the Road Vehicles (construction & use) regulations 1986 [and amendments] and European Directive 98/12EC.

Google and read…. It’s around 500 pages in total.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[TonyEmm]

I tow a 4x4 and I posted it to show how huge the A Frame market in the States is.

Also, given the America willingness to sue each other, if A-Frames were any where near as dangerous as you keep telling us, the A-Frame manufacturers would have been out of business years ago

Instead there are hundreds of thousands of A-Framed cars towed in the States, but I agree it doesn’t suit your narrative so you’d consider my post irrelevant

Here’s one from across the pond….

 

[eddie]

So why post irrelevant stuff from the States? And the page you refer to isn’t the law, it’s an advice page, written by the IVS division of the DfT.

The relevant law is the Road Vehicles (construction & use) regulations 1986 [and amendments] and European Directive 98/12EC.

Google and read…. It’s around 500 pages in total.

i assume you told the Government that their Website is wrong?

 

[eddie]

Here’s one from across the pond….View attachment 559627

Ah so American posts are relevant when you post them? I See

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Barclaybasher]

You haven’t seen the witness statements, the owner said folk ran for their lives…. I said myself that no-one was injured! Luckily, it was a Sunday, the nearby school wasn’t open….. The other side of that fence BTW is a railway line…. Things could have been a LOT worse….
View attachment 559625

You only quote the same SINGLE incident

Nobody injured..............so many 'what ifs'................ NOBODY INJURED !!

So much more wrong in the World...................... get some perspective!

 

[TonyEmm]

i assume you told the Government that their Website is wrong?

I am in contact with the Department for Transport. I’m not sure which is harder to deal with, them or this forum, the DfT stick their heads in the sand too..

 

[TonyEmm]

You only quote the same SINGLE incident

Nobody injured..............so many 'what ifs'................ NOBODY INJURED !!

So much more wrong in the World...................... get some perspective!

The system was illegal, that doesn’t bother you?

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[TonyEmm]

You only quote the same SINGLE incident

Nobody injured..............so many 'what ifs'................ NOBODY INJURED !!

So much more wrong in the World...................... get some perspective!

‘WHAT IF’ this had been legal? We wouldn’t be having this discussion!

 

[Minxy]

'Catastrophic' ?.............. One accident, 10 year old A frame, nobody injured?

....................Not even close!

............Much ado about nothing

..............One man's crusade...........

That's got to be one of the best jokes you've ever come up with .. remind me of which bank you hate????

 

[Minxy]

Nobody was confronted by a runaway car.....

Nobody injured, you clearly have an agenda............ find something that is a real (and proven) danger to campaign about

Looks like you need to go to Specsavers if you can't see the photo. Would you have been happier if someone had been squished?

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Barclaybasher]

Looks like you need to go to Specsavers if you can't see the photo. Would you have been happier if someone had been squished?

Has anyone EVER been injured by a runaway A frame?....................

 

[Minxy]

Has anyone EVER been injured by a runaway A frame?....................

I dunno ... why don't you find out for yourself seeing as you seem so interested ...

 

[eddie]

I am in contact with the Department for Transport. I’m not sure which is harder to deal with, them or this forum, the DfT stick their heads in the sand too..

Make sure you tell them that the Government have got it wrong as well on their web site?

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Chris]

Still thinking of A framing it to Spain this year.

Its all legal isn’t it?

 

[TonyEmm]

Still thinking of A framing it to Spain this year.

Its all legal isn’t it?

No, it isn’t.
That doesn’t mean you’ll get nicked, many do it each year and have no issue, BUT, it’s not legal .
Be aware, there is a risk.

Spain.



Para 8 refers to A-Frame towing.



The Spanish traffic law is absolutely specific.

It ain't a grey area here.

It has always been (I say always, but maybe only for the last, say, 50 years) illegal to tow one road vehicle with any other road vehicle on any public road anywhere in Spain.



For anyone needing really serious assistance in nodding off, here's the actual definitive Instructions on that law, together with other Spanish laws as they affect motorhomes being used on Spanish roads, issued in 2008 to all Police forces across the country by the Spanish equivalent of the UK Transport Minister:







Instrucción 08/V-74



Asunto: Autocaravanas

Instrucción 08/V-74

El constante crecimiento que ha experimentado en los últimos años el movimiento del autocaravanismo en

España y la falta de una regulación específica de algunos aspectos relacionados con esta actividad, motivaron la

aprobación en el Pleno del Senado de una Moción instando al Gobierno a tomar medidas necesarias para apoyar

el desarrollo de ésta*práctica y regular el uso de las autocaravanas.

Por este motivo, la Dirección General de Tráfico ha entendido necesario recopilar e interpretar en un único

documento todos aquellos aspectos normativos que, relacionados con el autocaravanismo, se recogen en la

legislación sobre tráfico y vehículos a motor.

 

[TonyEmm]

Make sure you tell them that the Government have got it wrong as well on their web site?

They have been informed.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Chris]

No, it isn’t.
That doesn’t mean you’ll get nicked, many do it each year and have no issue, BUT, it’s not legal .
Be aware, there is a risk.

Spain.



Para 8 refers to A-Frame towing.



The Spanish traffic law is absolutely specific.

It ain't a grey area here.

It has always been (I say always, but maybe only for the last, say, 50 years) illegal to tow one road vehicle with any other road vehicle on any public road anywhere in Spain.



For anyone needing really serious assistance in nodding off, here's the actual definitive Instructions on that law, together with other Spanish laws as they affect motorhomes being used on Spanish roads, issued in 2008 to all Police forces across the country by the Spanish equivalent of the UK Transport Minister:







Instrucción 08/V-74



Asunto: Autocaravanas

Instrucción 08/V-74

El constante crecimiento que ha experimentado en los últimos años el movimiento del autocaravanismo en

España y la falta de una regulación específica de algunos aspectos relacionados con esta actividad, motivaron la

aprobación en el Pleno del Senado de una Moción instando al Gobierno a tomar medidas necesarias para apoyar

el desarrollo de ésta*práctica y regular el uso de las autocaravanas.

Por este motivo, la Dirección General de Tráfico ha entendido necesario recopilar e interpretar en un único

documento todos aquellos aspectos normativos que, relacionados con el autocaravanismo, se recogen en la

legislación sobre tráfico y vehículos a motor.

I will just bring loads of Pesetas with me and a few packs of fags to pay off the cops

 

[TonyEmm]

What makes you think that anyone knows? If the fitters of systems that have failed don't report it how to you supposed 'Joe Public' can find out?


From what's been said only one 'catastrophic' failure ... I suppose we should be grateful that there haven't been more like this ... that we know of!

Maybe, just maybe, making this accident 'public' will ensure that others check their systems and prevent others occurring, also it may encourage others who have had this happen to them to report it too which would no doubt keep you both (and anyone else who just want to dismiss this important issue), happy so that you then know it's not just a fluke ... it's a funny way to be happy though!

What I am really surprised at is that people who should be able to see the bigger picture seem to have myopia when it comes Tony - if you cannot rise above that bias it says a lot more about you than it does him.

I really, REALLY do not get your hostility to the threads/posts about this issue ... if I had found out about it and been the first to report it on this forum I doubt very much if I would have got the flack that Tony has.

There are times when I am ashamed to be a member of this forum ...

Let’s get back to basics, the naysayers and anti-anti-everything brigade have had their fun.

The simple fact is that, regardless of the failure of the A-frame in the current issue, the installation was missing a crucial piece of safety equipment. It had no emergency braking facility installed.
The company’s documentation confirms there are others out there, (there is an alternative procedure in their fitting instructions).

Even after a total failure of the a-frame, the car should not have been able to run away.

1. That, and similar installations are illegal.
2. Only a blind man would not accept that there is a risk to life.

Sadly, there appears to be a lot of ‘blind men’ in this forum…

My original post highlighted the fact that there is an issue with some installations from one particular company.
it also explained how to check and what to look for (no dismantling required) to ensure your vehicle is not included in the problem.

That’s it, in a nutshell. I’ve provided the info, do with it what you will.

#towsafeforfreddie

 

[TonyEmm]

I will just bring loads of Pesetas with me and a few packs of fags to pay off the cops

One member of another forum had to buy a car transporter trailer as well as pay his fine.

you might need more than a few fags.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Charente16]

Still thinking of A framing it to Spain this year.

Its all legal isn’t it?
[/QUOTE

If you are thinking of driving through France take note, it is also illegal to 'tow a car' here and that would also include one on a 'A' Frame. Whether you would be booked or not is another matter, but it is still illegal.

Robert

 

[eddie]

Sadly, there appears to be a lot of ‘blind men’ in this forum…

Blind? or just can't see the evidence as there is none?

One car doesn't make thousands dangerous. If the car had pulled broken away just after the installation that would be different, but my understanding was that the A Frame had been on for years. For all any of us know it could be a rusty as tin can at the bottom of the Sea, the owner may have made a mistake that day and fitted it incorrectly.

I'll happily stop posting if you stop trying to re-invent the wheel and keep spouting that A Frames are illegal and dangerous. Its perfectly acceptable to "think" that they are, the same as people are perfectly entitled to "think" that their God is great! and everyone else's "God" is wrong. The War only starts when people try to indoctrinate others into their "Belief"

As it is, anyone that disagrees with you is wrong, anyone that disagrees with you is "blind" anyone that disagrees with you has their head stuck in the sand, even your attempts to get the Department for Transport involved has frustrated you as they also have their "heads in the sand"

The Government have a web site that you can look things up it encompasses many things, even A Frames

A-frames

www.gov.uk

To you, even that is wrong!

There is a great book written by Miguel de Cervantes, about a well meaning chap who saw Ferocious Giants and had to battle them whenever he saw them! to the amusement of others who wondered why he was shouting at windmills!

 

[Steve and Denise]

This is very funny to read as I can only see one half of the thread eddievanbitz the other half is on my ignore list as I would assume it is the same repetitive drivel that was on here a few weeks ago.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}