Motorhome Toilet Emptied On Beach. (1 Viewer)

[The Old Man]

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-north-west-wales-44451017

Motorhomes could be banned from parking on a beach overnight amid a claim a toilet was emptied on to the sand.

Gwynedd council is also considering increased beach access charges at Morfa Bychan, known locally as Black Rock Sands, in Porthmadog.

Councillor Selwyn Griffiths claimed campers staying overnight had left a "disgusting" mess.

The council confirmed it is planning to bring in "additional measures".

Emma Walters, a warden at the Black Rock Sands Touring and Camping Park, claimed she had caught a camper emptying a toilet at the weekend.

She said: "When I told him it was disgusting, he said 'tough'. You have to be careful.

"People are very annoyed. It's not only a tourist area, it's a nature area."

The council said its beach staff "actively advise" vehicles they should not park overnight but owners of motorhomes and campervans were "failing to comply with the requirements".

A spokesman added: "The council will be taking action... additional measures being considered include significantly increasing beach access charges for motorhomes and campervans and amending the beach by-laws to include the prohibition of remaining on the beach in a motor vehicle overnight."

Mr Griffiths said up to 70 vehicles have been staying at the site overnight, leaving residents "very upset".

"People walk along the sand dunes and are disgusted by what they see there," he added.

Public toilets at the beach have also been used to empty toilet contents, according to Mr Griffiths - leaving them "clogged up... disgusting, overflowing."

 

[funflair]

Disgusting indeed BUT if they tolerate overnight parking of up to 70 vans what do they think folk are going to do, I mean using the public toilets not the beach.

High time the tourist authorities and councils woke up.

Martin

 

[Hettie's Crew]

“Ban em” will be the decision by our short sighted, over paid reactionary councillors. In France it’s “we need to provide them with facilities”
We just stopped at a Super U near Vannes today with three motorhome service areas provided free, including grey water drain, toilet emptying/rinsing, tyre pressure pump and fresh water at 2 euros if you need it.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Larrynwin]

Another own goal

 

[WSandME]

Emma Walters, a warden at the Black Rock Sands Touring and Camping Park, claimed she had caught a camper emptying a toilet at the weekend.

So why didn’t she initiate proceedings against the offender? At the very least, fly tipping!
Or was the camper just letting his grey water dribble out harmlessly onto the beach?

 

[funflair]

So why didn’t she initiate proceedings against the offender? At the very least, fly tipping!
Or was the camper just letting his grey water dribble out harmlessly onto the beach?

Even that should be unacceptable grey water should be disposed of down the grey water drain provided, OH there isn't one

Martin

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Kingham]

So why didn’t she initiate proceedings against the offender? At the very least, fly tipping!
Or was the camper just letting his grey water dribble out harmlessly onto the beach?

I would hope a warden from a touring site would know the difference between toilet waste and grey waste.

Difficult for an assumed off duty warden, walking on the beach, to initiate proceedings against a stranger, who may not have been next to his vehicle.

 

[bungy]

a warden at the Black Rock Sands Touring and Camping Park, claimed she had caught a camper emptying a toilet at the weekend.

as i put on the other thread...

whilst im not condoning the alleged actions at all...i will say that this line is very familiar from local newspapers on a number of places along that coast, none of which have ever been supported by any evidence.

In one place further down the coast it was actually proved by a local resident that it was the warden/owner of a local campsite who was creating the problem as they were actually loosing business

 

[Puddleduck]

“Ban em” will be the decision by our short sighted, over paid reactionary councillors. In France it’s “we need to provide them with facilities”

Yes, it does appear to be an opportunity missed by both the local authority AND the camp site.

The local authority should be aware that there may be a problem if there are 70 vans overnight on the beach and need to think why and is this an opportunity to raise cash (no not by issuing fines unless????) The campsite should be asking why people are camping on the beach if there is a campsite nearby ..... and adjust their business model so as to increase revenue and decrease nuisance.

I have used a public wc facility to empty the cassette and left it cleaner and sweeter smelling than I found it. I did NOT block the drain - I fail to see how liquid waste from the cassette would block a drain (well ours is always mostly liquid after it has been treated overnight).

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Ducto]

What an abuse of own responsibility. All staying in one of the most beautiful places in the UK alongside miles of golden sand, incredible views and clean water. These people make me sick, destroy it for everybody else and fouling the place up. No grey water anywhere, any time except the proper place. It's so simple to leave no trace or cause for complaint.

They've been talking about closing the nudist beach there because the ever present doggers wander away from the quiet places where proper nudists don't go and think their physique will impress the general public.

As has already been said "Another own goal"

 

[Ducto]

as i put on the other thread...

whilst im not condoning the alleged actions at all...i will say that this line is very familiar from local newspapers on a number of places along that coast, none of which have ever been supported by any evidence.

In one place further down the coast it was actually proved by a local resident that it was the warden/owner of a local campsite who was creating the problem as they were actually loosing business

That's good to know! Where was this place please and who was said miscreant?

 

[joka250]

Not wanting to comment directly on this thread but would like to add something I saw 2 days ago that sums up just how disgusting some people can be. Stayed a few days on a lovely well kept rural site in Croatia. All facilities very good and well kept, included seperate doggy wash and facility for washing camping equipment. Went to empty my toilet cassette and was appalled to see that someone had emptied theirs in the doggy wash. This sums up some of the people that we have to mix with. It will eventually impact on our enjoyment.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[bungy]

That's good to know! Where was this place please and who was said miscreant?

down the coast at fairbourne at the point. there was regular reports in the local paper about what had been witnessed over a period of a year or two but no evidence ever got produced, in fact no evidence where the cassets were witnessed being emptied either.

 

[Hettie's Crew]

On a site in Wimereux last year I came around the corner to discover a man washing out his toilet cassette in the pot washing sinks. No evidence that he had emptied it there but he was making use of the very hot water to rinse it out. Didn’t seem in the slightest bit embarrassed.

 

[Puddleduck]

Went to empty my toilet cassette and was appalled to see that someone had emptied theirs in the doggy wash. This sums up some of the people that we have to mix with. It will eventually impact on our enjoyment.

Yuck

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Anthea M]

Yuck

Double yuk!

 

[AXO66]

Mmmm. How do , we, part of the motorhome fraternity, engage with the authorities?

Should we?

Currently it seems that individuals do this?

Or does Any group or association liaise with them?

Is there any wish to try and organise some form of engagement so, to take this as an example ,point out the lack of facilities, ask about why no action taken
Against the culprit etc.

CAn the camping and caravan or caravan and motirhome clubs be pressuerised by motorhome members to react to our requirements . After all the chair or is president of the C&MH club is part of the tourist industry establishment. There may be ways and means to try and influence the authorities to enabke responsible motorhoming?

 

[Ducto]

down the coast at fairbourne at the point. there was regular reports in the local paper about what had been witnessed over a period of a year or two but no evidence ever got produced, in fact no evidence where the cassets were witnessed being emptied either.

Thanks but Do you happen to have the name of the newspaper and more precise location please

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Puddleduck]

CAn the camping and caravan or caravan and motirhome clubs be pressuerised by motorhome members to react to our requirements . After all the chair or is president of the C&MH club is part of the tourist industry establishment. There may be ways and means to try and influence the authorities to enabke responsible motorhoming?

The "clubs" are run very much as businesses and each owns their own site network. They are consulted by the authorities as representing the interests of campers however it is open to debate as to how independent or representative they actually are.

 

[ShiftZZ]

I was in boulogne sur mer a few years ago and approached by a Brit motorhomer, who asked me where I emptied my grey and dump le poo poo. I explained I went to a local campsite and paid a couple of euros He was surprised he said why bother. Just do as he did dump it in the harbour.
Now no motorhome.

We can complain as much as we like, there will ALWAYS be a small minority who WILL spoil it for EVERYONE

Catering for motorhomes in the UK is never going to be a vote winner If you can afford to buy and run a motorhome then you can afford to stay and pay at a campsite. That appears to be the logic and now the bandwagon has moved on and campsites now charge for everything Dogs, awning, farting.

 

[sdc77]

I think that just because a local authority doesn't provide rescources it's no excuse for people to dump rubbish/effluent/waste water etc...
It's ok calling for 'evidence but we all know it's happening.
If the council want to increase charges then so be it... for all those comparing us to France we're not France and to experience France you have to go there .
The problem again seems to be a minority that want everything for nothing with no responsibility. Sadly

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[MikeD]

I am slightly confused - a warden of a local camp site caught some one dumping black waste.

No Regn of the vehicle or id. No prosecution etc.

And people are surprised/shocked?

Or maybe I missed something?

 

[johnp10]

I am slightly confused - a warden of a local camp site caught some one dumping black waste.

No Regn of the vehicle or id. No prosecution etc.

And people are surprised/shocked?

Or maybe I missed something?

I was thinking the same.
All this relies on "a claim" that someone dumped black waste on a beach.
Whilst it's believable, there seems to be a lack, even an absence, of evidence, as you point out.

Everything hangs on a report by a warden from a local campsite.
Vested interest?

 

[ShiftZZ]

The issue is that there will be a subconscious link between this dumping and the mess created by travellers. So a fair trial /hearing is not going to happen.
If anything I suspect the rules may get tougher.
reap what one sows

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Bobby22]

If anything I suspect the rules may get tougher.
reap what one sows

This reminds me of a situation last year at Dornoch, local campsites owners complained to local council reporting black waste being dumped on the dunes.

As i said then and believe now the hire fleets that supply sat navs pre loaded with wild/ free camping spots need to also advise the correct protocol surrounding black waste. People that hire motorhomes for short peoriods don't give a monkeys about the bad reputation they are creating.

 

[CazPaul]

So was the registration number and further steps taken against the motorhomer?
Need more information.

 

[Freespirit1]

The "clubs" are run very much as businesses and each owns their own site network.

Yes - and this site is no different!!

Probably all Fake News again

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Kingham]

I would hope a warden from a touring site would know the difference between toilet waste and grey waste.

Difficult for an assumed off duty warden, walking on the beach, to initiate proceedings against a stranger, who may not have been next to his vehicle.

@WSandME After reading some of the comments in the other post that is running on this subject, about links back to caravan site owning connections and counsellors, I formerly retract the earlier comments I made

The warden's report may indeed be spurious and mischievous

https://www.motorhomefun.co.uk/foru...mers-i-sometimes-despair.177507/#post-2879842

 

[jongood]

IF this happened then I think the culprit should be prosecuted ( or preferably shot!)

We've enjoyed staying on Black Rock sands.

Before the FLT chants start -

1, We have no problem paying for stuff that is good/worth it.

2, We left no waste of any kind.

3, We've also stayed on some of the campsites and they re pretty poor. None of them have a sea view - like barmouth they re behind the dunes.

Its about time the council upped their game and started trying to tempt more motorhomes etc. by offering modern world solutions not crappy old campsites that have barely changed since the war.

We were in Barmouth yesterday afternoon and the parking was more or less empty. there is a large carpark at the end of the prom which was totally empty yet overnight staying is banned. Instead you are expected to stay in the campsite which has a pretty poor access, very cramped and totally hidden from the beach by the railway line - attractive? Not.

 

[jezport]

So why didn’t she initiate proceedings against the offender? At the very least, fly tipping!
Or was the camper just letting his grey water dribble out harmlessly onto the beach?

Because she is a warden at a camp site so she is telling porkies.

I queried Scarborough council when a similar statement was in the press. I asked where and when it happened. Their reply was the report was anecdotal! Oh Please! what a bunch of corrupt bar stewards

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}