Black tank smell in MH (1 Viewer)

[Arthur01]

Pong

Looks intriguiing, just need to find a vent to attach it to now!! But thanks

David

David
In your photo No4 there seems to be possibly a roof vent just near the side door which is where the Cyclone vent would be positioned, as you moved along it draws the pong out with it. When stationary the vent turns to the direction of the prevailing wind & still draws the pong out.

Regards

Arthur.

 

[DavidG58]

David
In your photo No4 there seems to be possibly a roof vent just near the side door which is where the Cyclone vent would be positioned, as you moved along it draws the pong out with it. When stationary the vent turns to the direction of the prevailing wind & still draws the pong out.

Regards

Arthur.

That vent is directly above our oven, although it might be coupled in to the toilet vent system this seems unlikely, still hunting!!

David

 

[TheCaller]

That vent is directly above our oven,

Do ovens have roof vents? Pretty sure ours doesn't.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[DavidG58]

Do ovens have roof vents? Pretty sure ours doesn't.

Good point, I don't know either, but it would be odd to bring the black tank vent so far along the MH. But then everything else about this toilet seems to be a one off!! I will go up and have a sniff

David

 

[DavidG58]

Do ovens have roof vents? Pretty sure ours doesn't.

It is also directly above the fridge, which is under the oven (daft idea as well, but I only bought it) maybe the vent is for the gas part of the fridge??

David

 

[maz]

Do ovens have roof vents? Pretty sure ours doesn't.

Some ovens have roof vents, some have wall vents and some just vent into the van like a domestic oven.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[DavidG58]

Some ovens have roof vents, some have wall vents and some just vent into the van like a domestic oven.

I think I need to cook something and sniff, got to be better than hunting for the black tank vent!!

 

[Snowbird]

Forget the oven. Its nothing to do with the smell, unless of course you are cooking Fray Bentos pies whilst travelling

 

[DavidG58]

Forget the oven. Its nothing to do with the smell, unless of course you are cooking Fray Bentos pies whilst travelling

Just wanted to confirm what the only vent I seem to have is doing?

Could it be combined. fridge, oven, black and grey tanks or is that as dafty as it now looks written down

David

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Snowbird]

Just wanted to confirm what the only vent I seem to have is doing?

Could it be combined. fridge, oven, black and grey tanks or is that as dafty as it now looks written down

David

No chance whatsoever.

 

[DavidG58]

No chance whatsoever.

So would you think the vent on my roof is kitchen related or could it be waste?

Due to position over oven I presumed kitchen hence the sniff test to prove

David

 

[Snowbird]

So would you think the vent on my roof is kitchen related or could it be waste?

Due to position over oven I presumed kitchen hence the sniff test to prove

David

That vent looks like a water heater or gas heater vent to me. More like a gas boiler vent than anything. Switch the boiler on and see if heat rises. If not then switch the boiler off and switch the heating on and see if heat rises. If not it will be the vent to the black tank.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Snowbird]

Just had a thought....Do you have a ceramic hob ?.

 

[pappajohn]

the pillar vent in pic 4 is either the fridge or heater/boiler vent...or even combined

the white vent (pic 3) under the aerial is possibly the tank vent....doesnt look big enough for gas exhaust.

just cant see gas flue and black/grey vent being combined.....methane/sewer gas and open flames dont mix....well they do, with a BANG !!!!.

 

[DavidG58]

That vent looks like a water heater or gas heater vent to me. More like a gas boiler vent than anything. Switch the boiler on and see if heat rises. If not then switch the boiler off and switch the heating on and see if heat rises. If not it will be the vent to the black tank.

Just had a thought....Do you have a ceramic hob ?.

No, just a standard gas hob

The heating / boiler is Alde with a side vent alongside the boiler next to garage

So that vent is looking more likely to be black tank??

Still no idea what to do if it is, if blocked no problem dropping water down, if split could be a big mistake oh:

Many thanks for your continued interest, I was beginning to think trade in was best option!!

David

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[maz]

So that vent is looking more likely to be black tank??

How about lighting the oven and seeing if vent gets hot?

 

[DavidG58]

the pillar vent in pic 4 is either the fridge or heater/boiler vent...or even combined

the white vent (pic 3) under the aerial is possibly the tank vent....doesnt look big enough for gas exhaust.

just cant see gas flue and black/grey vent being combined.....methane/sewer gas and open flames dont mix....well they do, with a BANG !!!!.

The little white thing in pic 3 is odd, definitely not a vent, it has a screw of top, the thread M4 ish is the only outlet. I think it might be a radio aerial, but that is mainly due to location next to status

The pillar vent I think must be kitchen fridge and or oven, it is directly above both

David :thumb:

David

 

[Snowbird]

The reason I asked about the ceramic hob is that I have one and its vented through the roof with the same type of exit. So I would imagine that is similar. Vent exits are much the same whether they are heat or tank vents. If its a heat vent, obviously you do not want to pour water down it.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[DavidG58]

I think Pappajohns logic is pretty sound, you would not expect the black tank vent to be taken so close to the oven

I am not much further forward but intend to light the oven tomorrow to see if the only vent I have found gets hot

Then back to looking for replacement MH!! with cassette toilet!!

David

 

[Snowbird]

I think Pappajohns logic is pretty sound, you would not expect the black tank vent to be taken so close to the oven

I am not much further forward but intend to light the oven tomorrow to see if the only vent I have found gets hot

Then back to looking for replacement MH!! with cassette toilet!!

David

Ooooh...Thats a bit drastic. Give me a black tank any day. Empty it once a fortnight, not twice a day :Cool:

 

[DavidG58]

never did resolve this one, still get a smell issue if we drive with a window open for any amount of time, same applies to open roof vents which we don't do as a norm but it works as a good reminder that I have forgotten one

I am now 99% sure we have a floor mounted air vent to the black tank, this seems to be linked back up to just below the macerator keeping it above the top of the tank level at all times

the pipe has a peculiar plastic valve that I will photograph later, this has the whiff of black tank and a small residue of toilet tissue evident, hence my 99% hope this must be the vent. It has a screw on top that can be removed completely

I will be removing and giving it a poke through to be sure it is clear, it only has about a 10mm bore if that

Nothing about the tank or valve at all in the manual, I am pretty sure my MH is full of trial items, most of them abandoned immediately after fitting to mine

Photos to follow

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Chris]

Just googled the problem. Does this help?

https://axleaddict.com/rvs/How-to-Make-Your-RVs-Black-Water-Tank-Smell-Better

 

[Allanm]

We have a cyclone roof vent on ours and last week we got the awful sewer smell inside the van. The tank hadn't been emptied for 2 weeks and it wasn't really very full. No smell at all out of the toilet itself, even with the flap open and looking down the hole at the contents!
I think the wind was in the wrong direction, blowing directly past the cyclone vent into the back of a nearby roof vent cover.
Anyway, I emptied the black tank.
I have considered using a home made deodoriser consisting of Calgon water softener, washing powder and bleach ( google it, lots of recipes online) otherwise it seems the smell is contained for just over a week, then it starts to emit the smell.
Look forward to the pics from,this has been a problem for you for almost 3 years!

 

[DavidG58]

Thanks @Chris, that looks to be a useful read, will do properly later

funnily enough when I googled the problem. after the ads the next finds linked back to my original question here on MHF hence my reopening an old thread

I think we might be over careful on use of water to flush, that ties in with the linked suggestions

edit - as we have now managed the window related issues we now only get the smell problem immediately after the loo is flushed, not helped by the vent being effectively into or at best only just under the garage, right under our bed

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[peterc10]

David what you need is some decent clean Kentish water in your clean tank - the flushing will add all the chemicals you need

 

[Jaws]

Just googled the problem. Does this help?

https://axleaddict.com/rvs/How-to-Make-Your-RVs-Black-Water-Tank-Smell-Better

Had to grin at that article..
I used to work on a lot of USAF bases and the plumbers in the DIN trucks would often comment that for a race of folk who are almost obsessive about cleanliness their toilets and bathrooms were very often errr.. lets say not the most sanitary !

The average septic ( pun not intended LOL ! ) seemed to be completely averse to properly cleaning either the toilet of bathroom facilities in their base housing..
Absolutely no idea why !!

 

[DavidG58]

right then, photographic update, from start to end of process

first comment having read back through my own thread, I didn't even realise un til a year after I had bought it that this toilet is plastic not ceramic as I quoted three years ago

everything disappears through the round window no flaps or valves, but there is a chopper blade behind loo that chops and pushes water and contents into black tank below, we keep this lower part of the bowl full of water, although there is a sort of U bend, this is a guaranteed seal

only Hymer could fit a microprocessor driven loo, the rubber boot in middle is attached to the outlet from inside, which then lift the poo soup up and down the black hose to the left which is simply a cover to a clear plastic smaller pipe inside. The braided hose is the water flush connected to the main water tank and pump, In the middle bottom is an opaque (possibly poo coloured) pipe connected on the outlet side of the chopped poo soup leading down to below the garage with a funny valve on it, this must be the vent to the black tank I reckon, certainly cant find anything else that could be the vent

the next is the outlet from what I think might be the vent connected to a little vent / valve that is not mentioned in the book of words anywhere

the centre of the funny thing removed, hole through is clear of anything, but the bit whiffs to confirm it is connected to the loo

the o ring forms a seal, the thread allows the bottom plunger to be lifted, it looks like when screwed down this 'valve' is closed, so I have lifted it up (unscrewed it), this allows air to pass in or out through the small bore tube below, cut off at an angle and passed through sealant in the floor of MH

this is the release valve, in photo above I have my discharge hose connected, it sticks down about 3" from floor

last photo is of the chopper blade, with boot removed, the 'opaque' tube is connected on the underside of the square section behind the chopper, not really sure why it on the bottom, the top would make more sense if an air vent, but it not adjustable, so unless incorrectly fitted by Hymer it is where it should be

I am now of the opinion having read through the link sent by Chris, thanks again for that, that we have gone too far in our minimising water use so as not to need to empty as often

I also think we maybe don't add enough Bio liquid for the size of the tank, just added nearly a litre of Bio liquid, half a bottle of bleach and 10 litres of water ready for next journey to give it all a good shake out before used next

Hopefully this might sort it, but I am still not sure I have found the vent pipe to the black tank, but the top of the tank is totally inaccessible without dismantling the rear end of MH. will see if this does the trick first, I do wonder if we have a vent on top of the black tank that was never connected to anything. (there is no spillage though and we have driven home with it pretty full) The odour issue is most pronounced immediately after flushing, when air will be forced out of the black tank to somewhere

Anybody still reading, thanks for your interest

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[DavidG58]

while I was typing all that guff above, I got to thinking I must be able to see more of the black tank from somewhere, so have been taking panels off in the garage

now it is even more intriguing but slightly clearer, going back to photograph the revised findings

will post more in a bit, looks like a Hymer design flaw, as I have found a loosely fitted corrugated pipe coming out of the top of the black tank, which will almost certainly now be the vent pipe, but I have no idea where it goes and suspect it doesn't go outside

The tanks are all above floor level, fresh, grey and black, so unless this pipe goes down to somewhere below floor where I cant see it, its no wonder it stinks when we flush it, even the loose fitted vent connection is probably enough

 

[peterc10]

The white thingy with the O rings looks like an air admittance valve. If it is then it is there to let air into the sealed system to prevent a vacuum forming, but not let air (and therefore bad smells) out. If you are feeling lucky you could always try blowing and then sucking. You should be able to blow air in, but not suck any air out. But if I am wrong you could end up with a mouthful of s**t. Well at least its your own.

 

[hilldweller]

But if I am wrong you could end up with a mouthful of s**t. Well at least its your own.

That is just so comforting to him.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}